Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: How A Letter From Tom Coughlin Helped One Fan's Recovery

NCAA Tournament 2010 - This is a Joke, Right?

I have some questions.  What drugs was the selection committee on when they drew up the 2010 NCAA Tournament?  Did they watch basketball over the past month?  Have they ever watched a game of basketball?  Is Coach K on the committee?  Is Dick Vitale on the committee?  Are all members of the committee on Duke's faculty?  Did Bill Self sleep with a committee member's wife?  Did Bob Huggins sleep with a committee member's daughter?  Does someone on the committee want to sleep with Jay Wright?  Did the committee mix up Georgetown and Villanova's resumes because they are both catholic schools?  Is there a real bracket that is coming out later?  

Wtf_medium


(More after the Jump)

Star-divide

Midwest:

Here's what Kansas gets for being the best team in the country - a #2 seed with the best player in the country (Ohio State), a #3 seed that has beaten two #1s (Georgetown), a #4 seed that won the ACC (Maryland), a #5 seed that won the Big 10 and went to the finals last year (Michigan State), and a #6 seed that beat the other two #1 seeds (Tennessee).  Five of these six teams would CRUISE through the South region.  I cannot get over how stacked the Midwest is.  Kansas, Kentucky, Syracuse, West Virginia, Ohio State and Georgetown are the six best teams in the country right now.  3 of them are in the Midwest.  Not one is in the South.  I'm going to lose my mind.

One bright spot is this bracket is incredibly disrespectful to Georgetown.  As we saw this past week with Revenge Tour 2010, the Hoyas respond pretty well to adversity.  I can guarantee that not a single expert will pick Georgetown to get to the Final Four.  Band together and start wrecking house.  I hope the team is as enraged as I am right now.  My poor keyboard is getting pounded worse than that dude Manny Pacquaio destroyed last night.

With all that said, I still like this draw for Georgetown.  The beauty of it is there are no Big East teams there, and if you were paying attention the past week, it's been abundantly clear that the Big East is far and away the best conference in basketball.  Teams that rely as heavily on one player as Ohio State relies on Evan Turner have not done well in recent years, just look at Kevin Durant and Texas in 2007 and Michael Beasley and Kansas State in 2008.  Tennessee is an athletic team, no doubt about that, but they were 4-5 on the road, and lost their last game by 30 points.  Now for the elephant in the room, the Kansas Jayhawks.  They are clearly phenomenal, and I'm not going to say anything bad about them other than I think we match up better against them than we match up against Kentucky or Syracuse.

The Pick:  Georgetown.

South:

So let me get this straight.  Duke wins a weak ACC Conference, gets smoked by Wisconsin and Georgetown, and ends up with Villanova, Baylor and Purdue as their 2, 3 and 4 seeds.  Villanova has lost 5 of its last 7, and it is considered the 6th best team in the country by the committee.  Baylor has two quality wins this year - Texas and Texas.  Every game they were supposed to win, they won, every game they were supposed to lose, they lost.  And that's worthy of a #3 seed?  Purdue lost its best player and its last game by 27 to an 11 seed.  This is the route Duke faces?  What is going to make me laugh is when Louisville upends them in the 2nd round.  I've never, ever hated Duke or the NCAA more than I do right now.

The pick:  Winner of Winthrop / Arkansas-Pine Bluff.

West:

Shocking to me that a team that goes 28-4 in the toughest conference in basketball somehow gets passed by Duke.  Syracuse has a pretty nice bracket, but it's not the South.  Then again, Louisville is in the South, so Cuse fans should be thanking their lucky stars.  Kansas State isn't that good, neither is Pittsburgh.  Vanderbilt always plays well in the tournament, but hard to imagine they give Syracuse much of a scare. 

The pick:  Syracuse, very easily.

East:

Like Kansas, Kentucky should be furious with their draw.  People that actually follow the game, also known as writers, had West Virginia as the fourth #1 seed, not Duke.  Instead, Kentucky draws them as their #2 seed.  Also, if you've watched Kentucky and West Virginia at all this year, you'd know West Virginia is a terrible matchup for Kentucky because they have long armed defenders and rebound the ball like animals.  Still, I see Kentucky getting out of the region on talent alone.  Demarcus Cousins and John Wall are damn near unguardable.

The pick:  Kentucky.

If the brackets shake out like I've predicted here, we would face Syracuse for a fourth time in the Final Four.  Also, had the brackets shaken out differently, I could have easily seen Georgetown, Ohio State and Kansas all getting there.  I could not have easily seen Duke, Villanova, and Baylor all getting there.  The travesty is that the top 4 teams in the country do not have a shot to get to the Final Four.  How the Selection Committee could look themselves in the eyes and honestly think Kansas State and Villanova were the 5th and 6th best teams in the country is beyond me.  How the Selection Committee thought that Duke had a more impressive resume than Syracuse is also beyond my comprehension. 

There is no rhyme or reason to the committee's decisions either.  They disregarded Villanova's last 7 games, yet punished Syracuse for theirs.  I have no idea why Kansas State is considered the 5th best team in the country when their best win came against a #8 seed.  In the NCAA Tournament, you have to play good teams, I understand that.  Unfortunately a team that is not very good will be in the Final Four, and that has been decided before the first tip-off.  I'd write more, but my head is about to explode from rage.

Comment 61 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

We have finally found something to agree with

the brackets are amazingly unbalanced. If Syracuse was in the South, I wouldn’t be as mad because the South is a joke. But if I was a Kentucky or Kansas fan, I would be dumbfounded. The committee has tried to roll out a red carpet to Duke to the Final Four, and their toughest game will probably be in the second round, so I hope it backfires.

Homer: Aw, twenty dollars! I wanted a peanut!
Homer's Brain: Twenty dollars can buy many peanuts!
Homer: Explain how!
Homer's Brain: Money can be exchanged for goods and services!
Homer: Woo-hoo!

by bigbluethruandthru on Mar 14, 2010 8:40 PM EDT reply actions  

YEah

I was saying the samething, why is it Duke always I mean always gets the easy draw. And the head of the selection committee starting talking out of both sides of his neck when he trid to explain Duke being ahead of Cuse. At first he says well we took into account how team finish, but then turned around and said oh well we took into account the teams whole body of work from November until now, if thats the case Cuse and WVU got hosed. They want Duke to win point blank. I hope somebody blow their asses out on national TV, Im so tired of this ACC biased bull, I really am, it takes away from college bball as a whole.

WE ARE GEORGETOWN NOW AND FOREVER

by AIR CRAWFORD on Mar 14, 2010 8:42 PM EDT reply actions  

Ugh so terrible

Come on hoyas, let’s teach them a lesson

I can have oodles of charm when I want to.

by aja32 on Mar 14, 2010 8:49 PM EDT via mobile reply actions  

Also if we make it as far as kansas

Greg will school aldrich

I can have oodles of charm when I want to.

by aja32 on Mar 14, 2010 8:50 PM EDT via mobile reply actions  

IT'S NOT FINE

I’M MAD

It's not you, it's me.

by JGD on Mar 14, 2010 8:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

Would rather be a 6 seed in the South

than a 3 seed in the Midwest.

No, seriously. We would be facing ODU (Revenge Tour 2k10) outside of the cursed McDonough, then Baylor, Villanova, and Duke (if they even make it that far).

I’m with JGD, this is a joke.

by Hoyadonkulous on Mar 14, 2010 9:16 PM EDT up reply actions  

Come on fellas

If you have watched college hoop for the last decade and didnt expect Duke to get treated like this, I question your intellect. The only thing that surprised me was that they didnt change the venues and allow Duke to play in Cameron or some other arena in North Carolina for the first 4 rounds.

by boumtje on Mar 14, 2010 8:57 PM EDT reply actions  

One game at a time my friends.....

that’s how we took care of business in the BET…..

by MerlinWilson'sSister on Mar 14, 2010 8:59 PM EDT reply actions  

No one is picking G'town

past the final 8, which is good. I like the revenge/payback theme much more than I like the ‘look out for G’town’ theme…

this team is highly capable. The next 2 weeks will be insanely fun, and intensely gutwrenching all at once. I’m excited.

as has been said…

ONE.GAME.AT.A.TIME.

by ghostofjoeybrown on Mar 14, 2010 9:02 PM EDT reply actions  

Wow....

I don’t get it either. Other than the potential of playing Baylor in Houston, I couldn’t have asked for a better draw for ’Nova.

You guys got f’d, but the Committee does this every year. One bracket is always cupcakes and one is always really strong.

Never mistake effort for achievement.

Ah, beer, my one weakness. My Achille's heel, if you will. - HJS

by Esteban d' Amur on Mar 14, 2010 9:09 PM EDT reply actions  

You are the friendliest blogger alive

Hopefully we get an all Big East Final Four. That would serve the committee right. Hopefully you guys, ND or Louisville comes out of the South, us out of Midwest, Wva out of East and Cuse out of West

It's not you, it's me.

by JGD on Mar 14, 2010 9:10 PM EDT up reply actions  

I see no need...

to trash talk when we aren’t playing each other. I’m not going make ad hoemim (spelling? God I can’ spell) attacks. I don’t believe in homerism. That’s not my style. I’m more interested in discussing the teams and games.

I’m all for ball busting when we play each other or a blog topic calls for it.

Never mistake effort for achievement.

Ah, beer, my one weakness. My Achille's heel, if you will. - HJS

by Esteban d' Amur on Mar 14, 2010 9:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

Makes sense

It's not you, it's me.

by JGD on Mar 14, 2010 9:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

If that happens...

do we get to act like SEC football fans????

Never mistake effort for achievement.

Ah, beer, my one weakness. My Achille's heel, if you will. - HJS

by Esteban d' Amur on Mar 14, 2010 9:26 PM EDT up reply actions  

I want...

All eight Big East teams in the Sweet Sixteen
An Elite Eight composed of Kansas, Kentucky and six Big East teams
AND a Big East Final Four.

Why so Syracuse?

by HoyaJoker07 on Mar 15, 2010 11:15 AM EDT up reply actions  

Agreed

‘Nova fan here too, and I agree that you guys and West Virginia got totally screwed. I could not believe it that a) Duke ended up beating Syracuse for the #3 overall seed, and 2) They don’t have to face WVU as a number #2. Unbelievable.

by eclair on Mar 15, 2010 9:09 AM EDT up reply actions  

Amen to that

Rooting for Hoyas and any other Big East team in the tourney not matched up against us. Would LOVE to see Louisville drum Duke in second round.

by beatcuse on Mar 14, 2010 9:19 PM EDT reply actions  

Agreed

‘Cuse alum here. Jim Boeheim is the best coach in the history of the Big East (just to break the rules I agreed to when signing up). I want an all Big East FF desperately, because 1) SU/Gtown in the national semi-final is something any real SU/Gtown fan has literally dreamed of, and 2) it would mean that Coach K and Calipari lost. No, seriously, I’ve had that dream. Dave Bing tosses an oop to Melo, who throws it down over Ewing and Mourning as the buzzer expires. JTII storms off the court as Esherick collapses to the floor in a sea of tears and failure. A beam of light shines down on Boeheim as he raises his arms in victory, while scantily clad Juli looks on approvingly.

by Sadler1 on Mar 14, 2010 9:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

Upsets

Our bracket looks extremely tough but that could change quickly with some upsets. I think SD St. has a great chance to beat Tennessee. Kansas may be in for some tough matches against Northern Iowa & Michigan St. I’m not overly impressed with Ohio St. They should have lost to Illinois in the Big Ten semis. Who is to say Ohio St doesn’t lose to the 7-10 winner. Our draw could start looking a lot better if there are some upsets. That being said…..I still think we got screwed !!

by Free Vee Sanford on Mar 14, 2010 9:43 PM EDT reply actions  

Only one thing missing...

Only thing I see missing from your analysis — you should have quotes around quality in Baylor has two “quality” wins this year — Texas and Texas.

Just imaging the hours of fellatio that Coach K must have dedicated to getting this bracket makes me feel all tingly.

by sanityonleave on Mar 14, 2010 9:48 PM EDT reply actions  

this

“Duke is going to be eating so many cupcakes in their bracket that by the time they get to the Final Four Freeman is going to be sharing his insulin out of pity after they get destroyed by Syracuse.”

…just made my day!

You deserve a Roy Hibbert elbow to the face.

by GeorgetownHoyette on Mar 14, 2010 10:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

what's the deal with

Moses Abraham? thought he was committing today

by NotJasonClark on Mar 14, 2010 10:59 PM EDT reply actions  

was supposed to be a midnight

thanks to twitter – speculation is now it may be the morning. according to the talk folks he was at Leos tonight – which means something.

by bunk moreland on Mar 15, 2010 12:24 AM EDT up reply actions  

From a WaPo article today

which went to great lengths to portray the recruitment as a toss up between Maryland and Georgetown, a quote from Moses’ handler or whatever you want to call him:
“He’s 6-9, sneaky, his length, he can cover a lot of area with his arm span. I think he’ll be more of a face-up four [power forward]. He’s physical, but I don’t think he’ll be that physical. And I think at Georgetown he’ll be able to develop a little bit more. He won’t have to always, always be underneath the block or always underneath the rim to be able to make it happen for him.”

We’ll see how it turns out. No word yet, right?

by timmadrid on Mar 15, 2010 2:23 AM EDT up reply actions  

no word

according to the twitterverse, could not pull the trigger between IU and Gtown last night. Supposedly today will decide. Caring less and less.

by bunk moreland on Mar 15, 2010 8:21 AM EDT up reply actions  

Moses waits on Mount Sinai for God's message

Update (8:43 a.m. by Alex Bozich) — Moses Abraham did not choose a school last night, says Dustin Dopirak of The Herald-Times. According to Dustin’s source, which is likely the same one we’ve been using, "Indiana is doing a great job" in the recruitment of Abraham. The source adds that Abraham will speak to Tom Crean again this morning, but that a timetable for a decision is "up to Moses."

by MerlinWilson'sSister on Mar 15, 2010 9:39 AM EDT up reply actions  

Probably - or he wants to wander the ncaa desert for 4(0) years at IU

The guy has said he wanted to be a priest or study law, I think Gtown has the leg up on both, He never even been to indiana and DC actually has a nigerian community. yet he this is still a tough call for him. smh.

Maybe his handler is holding out for pay as an “assistant” at IU.

by bunk moreland on Mar 15, 2010 9:51 AM EDT up reply actions  

Breaking the 10 Commandments

I was under the impression that this was a “no-contact” period for recruitment of Moses, meaning that neither Crean nor JTIII are permitted to contact him, a rule that is meant to limit last-minute bullying/buying by programs towards recruits.

Doesn’t sound like good news that Abraham can’t pull the trigger. Sounds like he was favoring Gtown but after IU jumped in late to the recruiting process, Abraham was been wandering more and more toward the other side.

Would picking up Moses hurt our chances of picking up Christmas for ’11?

by Hoyadonkulous on Mar 15, 2010 5:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

I think that we might be out of scholarships

with the next commitment……

As I have said before, the WaPost headlines would be terrific if they both played at the Hilltop:

“MOSES LEADS HOYAS TO PROMISED LAND!!
IT’S CHRISTMAS IN MARCH (madness)!!”

by MerlinWilson'sSister on Mar 15, 2010 5:59 PM EDT up reply actions  

this isn't a good sign

my understanding is that crean is already in dc or on his way to meet with moses once the ‘no contact’ period ends in a few days.

is there any way he doesn’t have jeremiah rivers talk to moses about how much he hated the hilltop while dropping off an entire suitcase full of dead presidents?

Casually.

by CasualHoya on Mar 15, 2010 6:47 PM EDT up reply actions  

its evidently is a huge saga to IU fans

But crean tweeted he is back in bloomington, even though “no contact” ends tomorrow. I think moses still leaning gtown but wants to think some more. IU still wants to bring him out to visit. Other than maybe coeds and guaranteed playing time, IU does not make much sense. Also Sims was a better ranked recruit, so other than a fantastic name, he is not a program changer – maybe Vaughn 2.0.

here is the misery for IU fans

http://www.insidethehall.com/2010/03/15/live-blog-the-decision-featuring-moses-abraham/

by bunk moreland on Mar 15, 2010 9:52 PM EDT up reply actions  

Moses descends from the Hilltop holding two stone tablets....

unfortunately (or fortunately), he dropped the 3rd tablet on the way down, and it shattered,…… and it said ‘Maryland’…..

by MerlinWilson'sSister on Mar 15, 2010 11:11 PM EDT up reply actions  

Our draw

is pretty awful, but the one seeding that I thought made the least amount of sense was Nova being the 2 in Duke’s bracket. I thought the reasoning the committee gave for giving Duke the overall 3 was that they won their conference tourney? So why then does WVU not get the 2 in the Duke bracket over Nova (which has also lost 5 of 7)? Makes no sense. At the very least you’d think that they’d be consistent in their philosophy with the first four lines of seeds.

Hoping SDSU can pull an upset on Tennessee…UT doesn’t play the defense that WVU plays, but they have those similar types of athletes (6’6-6’8 wingmen) that we have trouble matching up with (ala WVU). That said, at least we’re not in Temple’s shoes.

by chicken madness on Mar 14, 2010 11:06 PM EDT reply actions  

The Answer

To every one of your questions is: because it makes it easier for Coach K to get to a Final 4 for the first time in years.

by boumtje on Mar 14, 2010 11:12 PM EDT up reply actions  

Lunardi
Toughest Region
The Midwest appears to be the toughest region at first glance. It has the nation’s top team (Kansas) plus a pair of what could have been No. 2 seeds (Ohio State and Georgetown). It also has my preseason national champion — Michigan State — but I think we know how that worked out.

Casually.

by CasualHoya on Mar 14, 2010 11:13 PM EDT reply actions  

same article...
UNDERSEEDED: Temple, Tennessee, Northern Iowa, San Diego State, UTEP

Casually.

by CasualHoya on Mar 14, 2010 11:14 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yes they do, BUT

safe to say that if we make it out of this region alive, each and every player on our team will be elevated to the status of deity for the rest of Hoya eternity. I think we can do it. That makes me tingle inside.

by Hoyadonkulous on Mar 14, 2010 11:26 PM EDT up reply actions  

an enjoyable Lunardi line

“The South looks like a beefed up NIT field.” Heh.

KBE

by SirHoya on Mar 15, 2010 9:50 AM EDT up reply actions   1 recs

Nailed It; We Got Nailed

Jeff Green’s Dad you got it. I could vomit. I have no idea how I’ll ever fill out my bracket. My only comfort over here is that you and the bulk of the posters so far know what’s going on.

We (and KS, I agree) could not have been more thoroughly screwed. How the hell do you get out of the Midwest region without surgery? What softer berth can you get than the South region? I’d rather have drawn a 16 seed in the South (or even in the West) than a 3 seed in the Midwest. I could not hate the filthy blue devil worse. I am beginning to believe the conspiracy theories. Until we fix that all up, I will be rooting for AK-Pine Bluff/Winthrop with a passion. (And then, I’m sorry, I hate Pitino just a few notches down, Cal., who I see in what, one game annually?) BTW, how does Purdue rank? Go Siena!

Of course I hate everyone else in the Big East, but I have to stand up for us as a block. Where’s the respect? Everyone acknowledges that it’s the strongest conference in the country. In what way does the bracket show that?

Also, there are match-ups out there that it would have been a DREAM to see. A pleasure just to watch, now matter who won. Dreams? The committee gives us random idiocy.

by 87Hoya on Mar 14, 2010 11:32 PM EDT reply actions  

F Dookie V

Good thing I don’t live in the States anymore as I would have hated watching the games while Suckie V is calling them. I will laugh my balls off when a cupcake takes them out even before they get to face the Orange perverts.

Obviously...

by soya on Mar 15, 2010 3:05 AM EDT reply actions  

A Joke

It’s as if they want to do everything in their power to protect this image of parity. They have tried their best to make sure that the Big East and Big 12 don’t get multiple teams in the Final 4. 2 potential sweet 16 and one elite 8 matchup could feature all BE matchups.

 The postive I see for the Hoyas is no other Big East teams. I just think Kansas is good. That will be a difficult test. I think if Georgetown plays Kansas the winner will win it all.

by Patrick'sGoldCard on Mar 15, 2010 8:38 AM EDT reply actions  

For the Record

Guerrero said in his interview on the Selection Show that the only other team they looked at as a #1 was WVU, which I’m going to assume means they put WVU as the #5 overall seed, then moved them to #2 overall seed Kentucky’s region for some entirely unbeknownst reason. Absurd!

by Vee Sanford's Next-door Neighbor on Mar 15, 2010 10:21 AM EDT reply actions  

Yeah – the seem to have ignored the S curve throughout the bracket without reference to their other rules (geographic protection and avoiding conference matchups until particular rounds based on the number of teams from a conference in the field).

Their TV contract is up soon – so my favorite conspiracy theory is that this seeding was done to facilitate negotiations somehow. Although if it was I don’t see how.

Despite being the overall #1, whcih would mean getting the best overall at each odd seeding level – Kansas gets arguably the best #2 (Ohio State/West Virginia seems a push really for that title), best 3, best 4, best 5.

Meanwhile Duke somehow leapfrogged syracuse to be the #3 overall, but got what appear to be the weakest 2, 3, 4, and 5.

And – the explanation for why Duke is a number 1 dont’t stack up against West Virginia (conference tournament title in tougher conference), Ohio State (a double), and Syracuse (regular season title in a tougher conference). Placing Duke above all three of those teams is insane. I could see over Syracuse because a little slippage after the injury might be appropriate. But all three? No way.

When all the talking heads, many of whom have a fairly obvious pro-ACC bias (Packer, Bilas, Davis, Dookie V) as well as ones wo generally don’t (Raftery, Wynn, McDonough, Lunardi) all criticize the committee’s application of its seeding guidelines FOR THE SAME REASONS and not because their particular ox got gored, there is a problem.

Cursing Craig for leaving us 21 wins behind the bastards....

by PerryMcDonald'sRightCross on Mar 15, 2010 10:31 AM EDT reply actions  

WVU

I’m sorry but I can’t respect WVU. They “cruised” through the BET by winning 3 games by a combined 5 points! Cincinatti, a team we beat by 27 should have won that game. N.D. is still getting used to having Harangody back. And we blew it at the end. Sure they are strong and rebound like animals but they can’t shoot. Don’t be surprised if they go out early.

by class of 68 hoya on Mar 15, 2010 11:09 AM EDT reply actions  

Irrational

Seems like a lot of complaining for a team that finished 5-5 in their last 10 games, including losses to RU and USF. (RU and USF!) There are a lot of things seemingly wrong with the brackets this year, but GU as a 3 seed isn’t one of them.

by guitarhero on Mar 16, 2010 2:52 AM EDT reply actions  

they also finished 4-1 in last five games

with a win against the top team in the conference

and have a top 10 RPI. im fine with the 3. not in the same bracket as Kansas and OSU.

Kansas is the team that really got screwed though

Good talk.

by Hire Esherick on Mar 16, 2010 9:29 AM EDT up reply actions  

WVU got screwed also

Not getting a 1 seed, fine. But it looks like they were seeded below Villanova to get stuck in the same bracket as #2 overall Kentucky.

That makes NO sense.

Casually.

by CasualHoya on Mar 16, 2010 10:03 AM EDT up reply actions  

Glad we've cleared that up.

Apparently we should have been arguing about how overseeded they were at 3.

by guitarhero on Mar 19, 2010 11:07 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

It's like religion, without the guilt.

John Thompson Jr.

Bulldog_logo_small CasualHoya

Hero_small Hire Esherick

John Thompson III

Jg_small JGD

Jonathan Wallace

Henrysims_small hoyasincebirth

Images_small TheMidRangeGame